In 2004 the small town of Naul, on the Emerald Isle, was shocked by the murder of a beautiful young mother, Rachel Callaly O’Reilly, in her own home. Joe O’Reilly took the case to the media in an effort to track down his wife’s killer, playing the grieving widower. He gave interview after interview and pleaded into every camera that looked his way. However, it was all an act because Joe knew who the murderer was all along.